Frenchman landed with €148k legal bill after train ticket fine
A man has told French media that he is being forced to sell his house after a €50 fine for travelling on a train without a valid ticket escalated into a €148,000 legal bill.
A man has told French media that he is being forced to sell his house after a €50 fine for travelling on a train without a valid ticket escalated into a €148,000 legal bill.
Arnaud, 39, who lives in the Bouches-du-Rhône département near Marseille has spoken out after losing the latest stage on his ongoing legal battle that all began when a ticket inspector attempted to fine him for travelling on a train without a valid ticket.
The bill, which was imposed by Mâcon Court in 2024 and upheld by Dijon Court of Appeal in 2025, has been brought to public attention this week after Arnaud told Le Parisien that he and his now-estranged wife are in the process of getting a divorce and selling their family home due to the ‘disproportionate’ sum he’s been told to pay.
The story began with the death of Arnaud’s grandmother in April 2021, during the COVID-19 pandemic, when funerals had to take place within 24 hours due to the lockdown restrictions.
Arnaud boarded the TGV train from Aix-en-Provence to Paris, where the funeral was due to be held.
Because his wife worked for SNCF, Arnaud was able to obtain a ticket for the round trip, for the price of the €2.60 reservation fee alone, on the condition that he present his pass showing his entitlement as the family member of an SNCF employee.
However, he told the paper that he was unable to validate his pass at the station, and the on-board ticket inspector told him he would issue a fine.
The standard fine for travelling without a valid ticket is €50. People who feel the fine is wrongly issued are generally advised to pay and then contest the charge later - those who are unable to produce a pass upon inspection can reclaim the cost of the fine if they can provide a valid pass at a later date.
READ ALSO : ID, pets and smoking: 7 things French train ticket inspectors can fine you for
However, Arnaud refused to provide his ID in order for the fine to be issued.
SNCF says that he assaulted the inspector, which he categorically denies, saying that he later offered to pay the fine, but the inspector told him was told it was “too late - the process has already begun”.
At the next station, he was removed from the train by police.
Arnaud admitted to Le Parisien that he threatened the inspector with death, “but without touching him.” He said it wasn’t possible because the police tackled him to the ground.
READ ALSO : French train passenger fined €150 for using phone on speaker
It's at this point that the story moves from being a simple ticket fine to becoming a criminal case.
The SNCF employee was given five days of sick leave, later extended first to 8 days, after an examination by a doctor found a slight injury to one finger.
In October 2021, six months after the incident, Arnaud was convicted of insults, threats, and violence resulting in an Incapacité Totale de Travail (inability to work) for a transport network employee.
Arnaud received a €500 fine and was also ordered to pay a symbolic €1 to SNCF for "business interruption losses" and €850 in provisional damages to the ticket inspector.
Only once the victim - the ticket inspector - had ‘stabilised’ could the court decide the amount to be awarded for civil damages.
That ‘stabilisation’ would take 18 months, with the inspector having become severely depressed after the initial five, and later eight, days of sick leave given to him immediately after the assault.
By then, the list of damages had grown significantly, with the inspector claiming a loss of nearly €30,000 in potential bonuses, €15,000 for the injury to his finger, €2,500 for his weight gain, €10,000 because he had to give up boxing, and €8,000 for loss of libido.
SNCF, meanwhile, calculated a claim of €103,468 in connection with its employee's sick leave.
In 2024, Arnaud was ordered to pay €45,000 to the ticket inspector and €103,000 to SNCF.
Arnaud appealed, but in 2025, the Dijon Court of Appeal upheld the original judgement in its entirety.
Since then, he told the French media, his marriage has broken down and he and his wife have put their house up for sale.
SNCF has said that Arnaud was convicted "of serious acts of violence, a decision upheld on appeal."
It has also emphasised that the amount due to be paid in damages "was determined following a court-ordered medical examination".
Le Parisien said SNCF told them: "Payment of this sum has not yet been made,” and that Arnaud "can contact our lawyer to discuss payment arrangements, such as setting up a payment plan."